When you’re scrolling through social media, especially Tiktok, think about the illness fakers’ Reddit and think back to shows such as Benefits Britain, as well as looking back to experiences in life it becomes clear that a lot of the time the automatic thought is that someone is faking their disability, or making it seem worse than it is for the perceived benefits. If someone has a disability that isn’t obvious, like a missing limb people struggle to believe or have sympathy. This is especially true if that person is a woman, a person of colour or part of the LGBTQ+ community. I thought I’d delve into the history of this phenomena and discuss the reasons why this may still be the case today.
The perception that someone is faking their disability has been around since the old poor law was created, aiming to support disabled individuals. It is not a new thing and in fact, deeply imbedded into our society and culture. This perception increased in the 18th century when the news put out led to increased stereotyping of the disabled. There were attempts to differentiate the genuine from the fake and the good disabled and the bad disabled. This is a very black and white perspective on disability and it led to calls for welfare reform to be based on firmer medical principles and proposals to get the sick and disabled into the workforce.
The negative image of welfare claimants still exists in society today. It is inflamed by media and political parties demonising benefits claimants and stating that they will be tough on benefits in order to win votes. The result of this is also a negative perception of disabled people, especially those with disabilities that aren’t visible to the naked eye and the belief that people are faking disability for perceived benefits.
It is assumed that disabled people are lazy, milking the system and living an easy life on benefits. People also love to try and make things a competition. They feel bitter about the state of the country and will comment things like I have x,y and z condition and still work full time. As if disability is a monolith. Even within the same condition there is a lot of variation in severity. Just because one person has found a job that works for them it doesn’t mean that everyone can! Take ME/CFS, for example. Some people are bed bound and reliant on feeding tubes, others are able to work full time with difficulty, and there is a whole range of severities inbetween. People seem to think that just because they have chronic pain and can work or because they know an amputee or a wheelchair user who can work, then everyone can work. This is simply not true. There is so much complexity and grey area within disability and so many things that affect capacity to work. It’s also important to note that we often mask our symptoms and some of us have become experts at it! This takes a toll. With energy limiting conditions there is always payback from activities. It is that payback that is often not seen. We might be able to do something one day then suffer dearly for it the next few days.
People struggle to understand the concept of payback and fluctuating disabilities and instead seem to jump to the notion that someone is faking their disability for the percieved benefits.
And part of it, is that after many years of Tory rule, the country has been messed up so much that many people are struggling despite working full time. They feel jealous of disabled people and others claiming benefits, of the cost of living payments, the council tax discounts, the free dental care (if you can find an NHS dentist) and free prescriptions. They think disabled people who are unable to work have it good. Have it easy. They don’t realise that people claiming disability benefits are not living a life of luxury. PIP is meant to help manage the extra costs of disability. The maximum you can get in PIP a month is around £700, however scope has stated it costs around £900 extra a month to live as a disabled person on average. And PIP is notoriously hard to get, plus the majority are not eligible for enhanced rate daily living and enhanced rate mobility.
A lot of this fake claiming perception does come from bitter people believing we have it easy. But the benefits system has caused suicide attempts, both successful and unsuccessful. It is unnecessarily difficult, confusing, stressful and long. People often end up getting into debt whilst waiting for payments to come through! And if you are disabled and unable to work or only able to work a little bit, so claim Universal Credit, you are unable to save towards a mortgage and if you already have that mortgage you are unable to claim housing element payments towards it. This means being stuck renting, potentially for life.
I think a lot of the fake claiming or exaggeration of disability perception also comes from people not understanding that when it comes to disability benefits, the assessments are based on what you can do over 50% of the time. Most people have good days, bad days, or even good hours and bad hours. Just because you’ve seen someone walk more than 20 metres on occasion, it doesn’t mean they can do that all the time! And you don’t see the toll that will take. I think people also don’t realise that we may use aids, or adaptations to do things! For example, I struggle to hold physical books due to thumb pain so the vast majority of my reading is on my kindle, with a pop socket so my thumb doesn’t lock, or via audiobook. I know that’s quite a simple adaptation but the same goes for many areas of life for many disabled people. We find our own, often unique ways of doing things, or we have other people to help us along the way! Even paralympians with conditions that fluctuate receive comments that they are faking! Because people just can’t understand how someone can do a sport with that disability. When it comes to my conditions, and my main one being hypermobile ehlers danlos I don’t understand it fully myself. Why I can get injured doing the most basic of tasks but also climb (although not very well at the moment!). Disability is confusing and I do understand that. I think generally as a community, to those people who are willing to listen we need to get better at explaining why some things may be more difficult than others and what aids and adaptations we use. And those that clearly are just out to troll and not willing to listen, they are not worth our often limited energy.
There is also a belief that benefit fraud is higher than it actually is. Not helped by the media and the DWP producing adverts demonstrating a crackdown on fraud and encouraging you to report your neighbour. This makes people think fraud is a big issue. The reality is when it comes to disability benefits, 9 in 10 allegations of fraud given to the DWP have been proven to be unfounded. Disabled people, innocent disabled people are at risk of being wrongly reported for fraud. This can result in a highly stressful time, and lead to people entering poverty and their conditions worsening.
This fake claiming accusation is a big problem, I think everyone who talks about disability or chronic illness on chronic illness has received the “there’s nothing wrong with you” “your playing the system” “If you can film a 3-minute tiktok you can work” comments before! It’s a risk of sharing and trying to raise awareness in this climate. Especially if you have certain conditions that are deemed as “trendy” in the chronic illness space, i.e. Heds, POTS and co.
As someone with H-EDS, it certainly isn’t a trendy diagnosis or enjoyable to experience. If I could get rid of the full body manifestations of EDS I would. Maybe it seems trendy because there is more awareness so more people are getting diagnosed, but no one wants EDS. What people do want though, if they have been undiagnosed for many years is answers, a sense of closure, understanding and a path to move forward with their life. Be that answer EDS or something else.
Whilst around 20% of the population are disabled, I don’t think society realises this or has a real understanding or reference point of what disability is, besides media representation, and people with very visible disabilities. This means a lot of misconceptions are held about what disability is and what it looks like and how it affects someone because disability isn’t something that is widely talked about or something children are taught about in school. I know I was very ableist, especially internally until I realised I was disabled, because that’s the environment I was raised in. As children, we don’t know any different, as adults we have a responsibility to listen to disabled voices and learn from that.